In this essay, William Fulford discusses Alexander Smith (1829-1867), a
contemporary poet associated with the Spasmodics. Fulford focuses primarily
on Life-Drama and, like other contemporary reviewers, saw
great potential in Smith’s work. Though he criticizes Smith for
not being sufficiently widely read, and for his narrow range of meter and
metaphor, the review is overall a favorable one. Fulford concludes:
“Weighing its merits against its defects, seeing that the former
are the excellencies of great genius, the latter faults such as experience
and care may amend, my hopes of the future greatness of its author are very
high.” (558).
Notable in this essay are Fulford’s comments about
Smith’s youth. Much of Fulford’s criticism stems from
his feelings of Smith’s immaturity, and he argues that Smith
“must find appreciation principally with the young”
(548). Fulford was two years younger than Smith, and would have been
approximately the same age when writing this review as Smith was when he
wrote Life-Drama.
This collection contains 1 text or image, including:
The Oxford and Cambridge Magazine text
Scholarly Commentary
Guest Editor: PC Fleming
Introduction
In this essay, William Fulford discusses Alexander Smith (1829-1867), a contemporary poet associated with the Spasmodics. Fulford focuses primarily on Life-Drama and, like other contemporary reviewers, saw great potential in Smith’s work. Though he criticizes Smith for not being sufficiently widely read, and for his narrow range of meter and metaphor, the review is overall a favorable one. Fulford concludes: “Weighing its merits against its defects, seeing that the former are the excellencies of great genius, the latter faults such as experience and care may amend, my hopes of the future greatness of its author are very high.” (558).
Notable in this essay are Fulford’s comments about Smith’s youth. Much of Fulford’s criticism stems from his feelings of Smith’s immaturity, and he argues that Smith “must find appreciation principally with the young” (548). Fulford was two years younger than Smith, and would have been approximately the same age when writing this review as Smith was when he wrote Life-Drama.
Printing History
First printed in The Oxford and Cambridge Magazine , September, 1856.